DC residents overwhelmingly voted for statehood while Puerto Ricans have a right to self-determination

Uphold self-determination to end taxation without representation

Civil Rights Jul 9, 2022

Issue 25 • Week of July 3, 2022

Taxation without representation was the rallying cry that drove American colonists to rebel from Great Britain, and yet that slogan holds true for nearly 4 million US citizens today. How can we celebrate Independence Day when the residents of Washington, DC and Puerto Rico are denied their voice? How can smaller territories such as the US Virgin Islands expect clear next steps until the two largest status questions are resolved?

Both are unique cases. Washington, DC was conceived as a district where officials would meet for a few months and then return home, yet it has become a permanent residence for 700,000 people -- larger than Vermont or Wyoming. While Washingtonians are able to choose electors for president thanks to the 23rd Amendment, they have no representation in the Senate and their sole delegate to the House cannot cast votes on legislation despite constituents paying more federal taxes than 22 states.

Puerto Rico became a Spanish colony in 1492 and has been a US territory since 1898 so its residents have been at the mercy of others for an incomprehensible 530 years. Puerto Ricans have been US citizens since 1917, but they have no say in Congress or the presidential election despite being home to more veterans than 7 other states (AK, DE, ND, RI, SD, VT, WY). Their situation is a parallel to the citizens aged 18-20 who fought in Vietnam and were not allowed to vote until the 26th Amendment lowered the voting age to 18. This discrepancy has repeatedly shortchanged Puerto Ricans, especially during the federal responses to Hurricane Maria, recent earthquakes, and the pandemic.

How can we advocate for their self-determination, a core principle of international law and bedrock of American policy since WWI?

Tags

Surmountable Governance Issues

Governance issues concern the foundational life and liberty of our society through accountability, civil rights, equality, security, and survival.